HGG Community Forums

If she was crow hopping and bucking, I doubt she kicked you intentionally, sounds like that part was accidental. If your horse doesn't normally behave like that when you get on, that's a good indication that something is wrong and your horse was upset or in pain. Or maybe your horse got stung by a bee/horsefly and freaked out, especially because she's sensitive. When I was a kid, I used to lease a horse that freaked out and dumped me like that every time the bugs were bad and he just got too upset to handle them anymore. I don't remember my 13th birthday because he decided that bucking me off and giving me a concussion would be a great birthday present lol.

Have you had your saddle fit checked? If your saddle doesn't fit your horse right and it hurts her back or pinches her, that could definitely explain the extreme reaction when you got on her. There's a wide variety of English saddles out there and I'm not sure what kind you have, but many of them, particularly the close contact saddles (especially the french ones), are designed to fit TBs or TB type lighter WBs i.e. high, narrow withers and narrow tree. Based on your description, I'm guessing your horse is more of the QH type, and a lot of English saddles out there aren't made for horses with lower withers or a wide back. I know several people who have WBs that have more of the barrel type build with big shoulders and a low broad wither, and they've found that saddles with a hoop tree fit their type of horse better than the standard "A frame" type of tree you see on most english saddles. Here's a really useful post about hoop trees vs. standard trees if you haven't heard of hoop trees before.
http://saddlefitter.blogspot.com/2009/10/from-tree-up-hoop-vs-standard.html

Get rid of her. There are a million NICE horses on the planet. Your mare is not nice. Nice horses' don't send you to the hospital over and over again.

This mare has sent her to the hospital multiple times. These wasn't a freak one off.

Shes also had her for ten years. Anyone can fall off of any horse and get a few concussions whether the horse is a saint most of the time or the opposite. I'm not saying its acceptable at all. But I also don't think "get rid of the horse" is the first thing that should happen either. There could be so many things that come into play. If this horse was vicious she would have done much more damage over the last ten years. Not that what shes done isnt a lot of damage it is and I'm not excusing it. However I feel that if she wants to try and cares about this horse that she owes it to the horse and herself to cover all of her bases

Even the nicest horse on the planet can still send multiple people to the hospital even if it never deliberately misbehaves in its life. And that same wonderful horse can still do something dangerous and hurt you if it gets scared enough. This sport is dangerous by nature and there is no such thing as a perfectly safe horse. Riding horses is inherently dangerous and we try our best to minimize that danger, but it will never go away completely no matter what you do. Remember, you're sitting on top of a 1200 lb prey animal. Sometimes we forget that and expect horses to react to things the same way humans would. The only sort of horse that you can get on and 100% guarantee your safety every single time you ride is the kind that only goes when you put the quarter in. The reality is that you could get rid of this horse and buy a completely bombproof packer type and you could still end up in the hospital again. It would probably be less likely but still definitely possible.

Years ago, one of the girls at our barn was jumping her horse and leaned really far forward and jumped ahead, got jumped loose, fell off and hit her head, and couldn't ride for a month because she had a concussion. Her mom was riding the same horse while her daughter couldn't ride and she put her thumb over the horse's neck as it was jumping (huge no-no), horse's neck came up and back as it went over the jump, and the mom bent her thumb backwards so badly that she tore several tendons and ligaments and she needed multiple surgeries to repair the damage. If you were to judge that horse's safety based on how many riders it sent to the hospital, you'd say that the pony was really dangerous. In reality, that's clearly not the case.

That being said, we don't know this horse or what caused such an extreme reaction when she went to mount. And we don't know if the horse has made a habit of this sort of thing, and we don't know how her other accidents and injuries were caused. If the accidents were all caused by the horse misbehaving or deliberately trying to injure her, that's one thing and it could definitely mean that the horse has some sort of problem, maybe because something is physically wrong with the horse, or maybe because the horse really does have a behavioral issue. But if the other accidents really were accidents and were caused by things like rider error, horse tripping or stumbling etc, then that's something else entirely. We don't have enough information to know if this was just a one off freak accident or whether the horse is dangerous. If there is something wrong with the horse, then you should definitely not ride her until you can figure out what exactly is going on.

If you do decide to sell the horse, you need to be very careful and if the horse has some sort of behavioral issue it needs to be disclosed to any potential buyers. Otherwise, if the horse does the same thing to the new owner and they get hurt, you could be sued because you knew there was something wrong with the horse when you sold it and you failed to inform the new owner of that. Personally, if I decided that the horse was too dangerous to ride, I would retire her and not sell her, because even if you do disclose any potential issues to the new owner, they can still sue you. They might not win in that case, but it would still be a huge pain to go through.

If you decide to keep the horse, I would make sure that you have a vet look at her to rule out physical problems like Kissing Spine, and have the vet do a blood test to rule out things like EPM or Lyme disease. Lyme is a lot more common than most people realize, especially if you live in a part of the country where there are a lot of ticks around.

You could try desensitization training, but dangerous horses are just simply not worth it in my book. People make tons of excuses for horses they love but I think when you are messing with an animal as big as a horse you better pick a partner you can trust. At the end of a day it's just a horse. That pisses some people off to say but it's true. Your life and health are worth so much more. A good partner DOESN'T kick you in the gut because you slid off their butt. I've known countless horses you could do that on all day long and they would never flinch. Explosive personalities are just a bad combo with something as big as a horse.

This is just my opinion, since I have been in the medical field for 40 years. And also was raised and grew up with family breeding businesses. I have also ridden, bred and trained horses for 50 years. I have even had BLM mustangs (wild horses) come to me for training. And horses with behavioral problems for retraining. I always referred my clients to veterinarians first, to make sure it isn't a pain/medical the horse has. You have already done that. Speaking from a standpoint on both of these fields I have been in:

You have already had a vet look at her, so without actually being with your horse to observe her. She does not have a good temperament. Some do and some don't. Some can have the problems worked out, but usually not with a horse with a temperament yours seems to have. Out of the hundreds of horses I have trained from their birth, to older horses with problems, your horse is most likely one that cannot have her problems worked out. Plus, it can get very expensive with medical, vet and training bills.

With the injuries that you have had from this horse, it is not worth it to keep her. You could have long term medical issues later in life, with the injuries you have received from this horse so far. I know you love her, and its hard, but you need to sell her. Get a horse with a good temperament, that you can enjoy riding. Let the buyer know her history, but you need to sell her.

I can't say anything about the horse, not having one or having the chance to be around any hardly at all, but I want you to be very careful of yourself at the moment. A liver injury is not something to sneeze at. It is a very important organ in your body and you must get lots of rest and heal up. Listen to what the more experienced riders have said, and take this time while you are unable to ride to follow up on all the advice they have given you.

Very well said @Waldgraf!

I didn't read all the comments, so sorry if I repeat something that someone else has said! I had a little appaloosa mare that I had had for a while, and I absolutely loved her! But about a year after I had bought her, she started crow hopping when I rode her. The crow hopping turned into bucking though, and she threw me a few times. I never had to go to the hospital though. I was younger then (11 or 12), so I had no idea what to do. We took her to a trainer, and after a month, she was fixed! No more bucking or anything, and she was perfect! As soon as we took her home again, she would be back to normal and buck again. It took me a while to realize it, but when we took her home, I was too nice on her. I wouldn't correct her mistakes and I'd let her get away with things. As soon as show season started up, she'd get chiropractor work and dentist work done, and I'd be riding her 5-6 times a week, and she would never buck or anything! But as soon as show season ended, and I was only riding like 1-2 times a week, she'd be back to bucking.
I don't know what you do with your horse, but what I found to work is don't be afraid to be mean every once in a while, you have to correct their mistakes, or they'll know they can get away with things and try to do it again. But also reward them for good things, so they know when they're being good.
And this might sound weird, but if you haven't, try to get your horse's teeth checked by a dentist! My horse's dentist tells stories about horses that act totally different after getting their teeth done, because they were in so much pain before! One last thing, if you don't regularly ride, you might want to try to. Or even lunge if you don't have time to ride. With Sally, I tried to keep her as active as possible, and that seemed to improve her mood and it helped with her bucking.
Well, sorry for the long comment, hope you get better soon! And I hope everything works out with you and your horse!

I have to agree with Ammit on this and most of the other people commenting. You need to do one of two things:
1. Sell her to someone who is aware and able to fix her
or
2. Get people to help you look at her and find the issue before you even think about getting back on that horse.

Like other people said we were not there and it makes it very hard to make assumptions without seeing the behavior.
I was in the position at one time where we bought a horse, Thoroughbred/Quarter horse, who had multiple times put its owner in the hospital and the owner didn't let us know. This particular horse was down right nasty. She never did this kind of behavior when we went to visit her before buying her because the owner made sure she was tired out by doing round pen work by the time we got there. She not only would buck you off but then attempt to stomp you into the ground. It got to the point were only the men in our family were allowed to ride her. She was also a terror to catch. it took all of us and all of us was like 10+ people but we did it on a regular basis because we thought she would get better if we did. I remember one time she was actually doing really well with my dad riding her. You had to keep her reins very tight other wise she would bite you or grab the bit and just take you for a spin. She was a sneaky pretty thing. She was behaving and she tugged on the reins asking to have her head because she was doing so well dad thought it was a good idea and he let her have her head and she started to go into a nice trot. About 4 strides in she grabbed the bit pulled her head fully out and took off bucking like a wild bronco the whole way. My dad finally went flying over her head and landed flat on his back. She was coming right back down at his head so he started rolling. He got lucky as all of us were screaming and running toward him she just happen to step on her own rein so when she went to rear again she yanked her own head back down. It startled her and she stood quiet as a door mouse.
Moral to the story: Some horses are just nasty
We did end up selling her with full disclosure to someone who was willing and able to try and fix her. Ammit is right. There are so many really good horses who you can slid off the backside and they never move. Your young, and your health is at risk because of this horse. Sometimes when you love something so hard you really need to stop and think about what is really the best for them. Sometimes its sad and hard but your mom might be right. If your not willing to do that you really have to get help from the vet and other people to make sure your safe the next time you get on her.

Doesn't mean people can't still comment. Lol
Thanks for all the discussion guys. :)
Almost healed, working with her. We shall see..