X
HGG Community Forums
Log In to HorseGeneticsGame
HGG Community Forums
Join our discord server!
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Categories
- All Discussions68,241
- Announcements356
- HJ2 Discussion67,060
- ↳ New Member Introductions569
- ↳ Help me out3,469
- ↳ Horses For Sale and Auction12,515
- ↳ Breeding Ads and Sales3,456
- ↳ Herd Helper39,570
- ↳ Bug Discussion120
- ↳ Repair Log12
- General Discussion825
- ↳ Saddle Sisterhood32
- ↳ Games, Contests and GiveAWays54
- ↳ Genetics245
In this Discussion
- AztecArabians May 2017
- Coeur May 2017
- DragonRun May 2017
- kintara May 2017
- SandycreekFarm May 2017
Who's Online (0)
Comparison Test vs Stallion Paper Level
-
This might be a silly question, but is there a reason to comparison test a stallion against his father if he papers higher than his father? If my first stallion is C papered and his son is B papered and passes SBA, should I bother with a comparison test? I only ever use it when deciding which stallions within the same generation to keep intact.Red Rock Ranch
Home of the Rubidean Warmblood
Player #25583Thanked by 1JordanK -
I do not always test against the sire, but always do a comparison against my benchmark stallion. This breeding season I had two new benchmark stallions born, so that drove extensive comparisons within the generation.
-
No. If you have a stud that is papered C and his son papers B, then he is superior to his sire and there is no need to test him. Comparison testing is meant for horses that are similarly papered to see who is better. For example, if you have a stud that is B papered and his son also papers B you would test them to see who is superior or if they are as good as each other.
-
I have had B papered colts test about as good as their C papered sire. They are superior, but only slightly superior. If the sire has a considerable number of colts, you will probably find B papered sons that are superior to the slightly superior colt.
This morning, testing colts with this situation, I started with 3 B colts about as good as each other. Then I found a colt that was superior to them, so they got snipped. Finally I found a colt that was superior to that second leader and his peers, so they also got snipped. This was, I'm a bit ashamed to say, colts from three years of pasture breeding.De gustibus non disputandum. "There's no arguing about tastes."
SandyCreek Farm: ID# 441
also playing H&J1 as SandyCreek Acres: ID# 137592Thanked by 1kintara -
I always comparison test B papered colts from C papered sires, because most foundations stallion are very high C's and easily throw B papered colts that are only about as good as them
-
Highly recommend comparison testing!
I got this A papered boy out of my G2 A papered stallion. I initially assumed he'd only be AGA/inferior so was ready to snip once I'd tested. Put him through SBA and passed so comparison tested and he came back superior, to my surprise. There is a range in paper levels, so it gives a good indication on where the sire/foal is, where papering only shows the paper, not the range.
Foal:
III Fanciful Song HzKP
Sire:
II Whimsical Beau HzKPAztecArabians
~ Striving to breed exceptional, affordable Warmbloods ~
ID 19120Thanked by 1kintara