X
HGG Community Forums
Log In to HorseGeneticsGame
HGG Community Forums
Join our discord server!
Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Categories
- All Discussions68,241
- Announcements356
- HJ2 Discussion67,060
- ↳ New Member Introductions569
- ↳ Help me out3,469
- ↳ Horses For Sale and Auction12,515
- ↳ Breeding Ads and Sales3,456
- ↳ Herd Helper39,570
- ↳ Bug Discussion120
- ↳ Repair Log12
- General Discussion825
- ↳ Saddle Sisterhood32
- ↳ Games, Contests and GiveAWays54
- ↳ Genetics245
In this Discussion
- best friend December 2016
- Cheers December 2016
- ColorGoodStables December 2016
- ConfluenceFarms December 2016
- Maribo December 2016
- SandycreekFarm December 2016
Who's Online (0)
Is it the mares or my RS stallion?
-
My candy appaloosa has put several C papered foals on the ground and I'm not sure if it's him or the mares I'm breeding him with.
He does have several B papered sons (some that passes GA and some that havent) and it's makes me feel pretty iffy on their quality. Same with the fillies. I can't test them yet but I have a feeling they aren't the best.
I think he usually gets to breed between 15 and 20 of my mares each season and then around 5-10 public foals too----
Barn ID 4953 -
A Rank Special is always at least a perfect foundation, so it's not your stallion. It's not unusual to get some inferior, some equal quality and a few superior foals in every crop--regardless of the quality of the parents. If you can quantify that you are getting more inferior foals or an inferior Average Foal Performance Test score from this stallion's batch of foals, it's your mares you should look at first.
It's a bit of an old saw by now, but at some point in the past a player did an experiment breeding a perfect foundation stallion to all perfect foundation mares. Information on how they did passing testing I don't believe is available (and would be grossly out of date anyway) but the foal PT scores ranged from something like 8.9-10.4. Given that all parents had PTs of 9.9, that should give you an idea of the range produced within such breedings. We can extrapolate that the hidden breeding score would have a similar range, above and below that of the parents. -
Can you put up a link to your mares? Are they the same mares breeding to him?
-
What is his link?
-
I remember Ammit saying something about the odds of getting a superior. I might have my numbers mistaken, but I think it was like 1 in 20 if you are using two horses of equal quality, outside of pasture. Wich means, that if your horses are producing one foal of superior quality in every 20 (no matter if it is a filly or a colt), you are on the right track.
(superior quality as in would be superior in comparison testing, if you could comparison test both colts and fillies. Remember that alot of AGA will also be a little bit superior to their sire) -
In reference to the experiment breeding perfect foundations mentioned above, all perfect foundations have 100% breeding ability, which is the best non-exceptional creates can have. So there is nothing wrong with his quality.
However, even breeding foundations in pasture with mares that have spent 30+ days there, it's possible to get C papered sons.
In HaJ1, I have an exceptionally perfect foundation stallion (B papered) in pasture with foundation mares that are all exceptional producers who were in pasture 30 days before I bred them. He produced 17 colts. Four of them are A papered stallions that comparison tested about as good as each other. Of the 13 geldings from the crop, 3 papered A but were snipped because they are inconsistent. The other 10 all papered B and were snipped because they didn't paper higher than their sire. He also gave me 4 fillies that were spayed and 11 fillies that are still intact, although I haven't checked all of them yet for consistency. How they will do breeding, is, of course, unknowable until they have foals of their own, but all of the intact ones did pass SMA.
I don't remember exactly, but of all the pastures of regular foundations that I bred at the same time, I can recall there being a fair sized handful of C papered colts.
De gustibus non disputandum. "There's no arguing about tastes."
SandyCreek Farm: ID# 441
also playing H&J1 as SandyCreek Acres: ID# 137592 -
I just got a few C papered colts out of my gen 4 pastures, bred with mid-high A stallions. Now that is frustrating!!!
-
Cheers, if you are getting intact C papered colts for your 4th generation, I would think the quality of your 3rd generation boys is pretty low, I'm sorry to say :(
-
Not intact--gelded by GA and out of brand new mares I put in the pasture seconds before breeding it. My stallion quality is coming up, has really all come up in a bit of a rush over the last few seasons so my mares are just really starting to show how crappy they are at gen 4 and up now. It's ok. Growing pains!
-
Nah! I Gelding paper everything since it's free. I have found those mares that do throw a really low papered early colt often go on to disappoint me but I don't have enough evidence yet to start snipping them outright after that first foal. It's such a trial and error process!
-
On WHG Ammit had 'nicks' (aka niches); stallions and mares that, for whatever reason more often than not had better foals. We never really had time to play with it, and figure it out before the game shut down, but it was cool to know! That kind of thing messes up all the calculations! :P
-
I don't think I pay as much attention to my mate quality as I should. Really need to start keeping her track of them. I do think think I've culled a mare in almost 6 months.
Also need to do better with my upper gens, mares and stallion both. I've been a lot stricter with my Colts and culling them if they don't paper PT or meet a few other requirements. But upper gen mares almost always go in for breeding if they pass MA. Time to change that I think
My biggest problem is that a lot of my mares are favorites, I don't mind spaying bit I have no where to put them. I don't want to sell them either. Since I have no room to spay and keep as well as bring in a new herd it makes quality improvement difficult----
Barn ID 4953 -
Right now all of my foundation's mares are papering red. Hoping for a blue in the 2 and 3 generation groups.
-
Super uncommon to get Blue gen 2s. I have a handful but I use full pasture bonus for everything and some boosted gen 2 stallions.
-
Aw ok.
-
I require blue by 3rd gen. But I check AFPT on every mare every year. When I PT test the foals I pull up every one that is lower than what I want and check the dam, and if her AFPT is too low, she gets the snip (the dam, not the foal) and I stick her in a showing barn. I actually had to loosen up just a little last season, as I had to few mares for my liking (I had a few season that I was not breeding very much).
-
Hey Maribo! Maybe you can help me with a quandary I'm having in my gen 3 mare herd. I'm trying to transition to keeping only Blue mares and an AFPT of 11.0 or more. I have some Blue mares with AFPTs below this and some Red mares with AFPTs above this. Numbers aren't a problem--I have a back log of mares sitting in barns waiting for their chance. Should I just snip both sets of mares that aren't living up to my expectations?